It’s not that I don’t have any time. It’s just that I don’t have any time where I’m not thinking “I should really be studying now”.
But the news today finally got my attention. It seems only recently we were having a war against poverty. Now, it’s all-out war on the poor.
I really didn’t expect Clare County Council to be leading the charge though.
Some background: In 1977, during a boom not so unlike the one just past, Fianna Fáil bought an election largely by abolishing local taxation. From now on, the towns and counties of Ireland would be funded not by householders, but from central government. This situation was allowed to continue even after the economy fell face-first off a cliff in the early 80s.
After this latest crash though, and the terrible deals made to get out of it, they need all the money they can get. So if there’s an asset that can’t be hidden – like say a job or a house – a tax has been slapped on it. At the moment there’s only what they call the Household Charge, an almost token €100 a year. This is just a clever ruse though. They believe people will be shamed into paying it. What householder cannot afford €100? Look at all you get for it! But it’s a trick; what they want is to get people onto the radar. Ultimately of course they intend to charge us far more than €100 a year, but thanks to the intervening 35 there is no reliable and comprehensive registry of home ownership in this country. So a property tax would be an administrative impossibility – unless we are tricked or forced into volunteering the information ourselves.
That’s why they’re being such hard-asses about it. Central government is forcing local to force people to put themselves on the register, by the brutal tactic of declaring how many households there are in a given locality, and reducing central funding by that times €100. Local government will now run out of funding for services like water and sewage and waste – unless they squeeze it out of the people they’re supposed to be representing.
Another service local government funds – for reasons lost to time – is higher education support. What fee assistance and maintenance grants they provide though are heavily means-tested and only paid to the poorest. And now, in Clare at least, applicants will also be required to provide proof that their families have paid the Household Charge.
This is not right, and it’s not right for a whole bunch of reasons. It’s contrary to several important ideas about how society works. Are we really going to stop services for everyone who hasn’t paid their taxes? Other forms of education too? Hospital services, welfare? If so, then surely Bertie Ahern should have all his pensions withdrawn. Are we going to put pressure on parents by withdrawing life opportunities from their children? Will we discriminate against children and young adults because of the choices of their parents? Will we set families against each other to raise tax?
Yes, some people aren’t paying this because they don’t want to get on that register when they know they’re going to be hammered by a new property tax. These though are hardly the people who qualify for the paltry maintenance grant. Others refuse as a form of protest, because they consider it unjust that the ordinary citizen of this country is being forced at financial gunpoint to pay off the losses of multinational banking giants. And they are right, it is unjust. To pay this tax is effectively to hand money over to a banker; not money that you ever owed to a banker, but money that a corrupt government promised to this banker. Why would you pay that?
And then there are some who simply haven’t been able to spare that €100. This is an (inadequate) subsistence grant which only the poorest, remember, can qualify for. Making it a condition of educational assistance provides yet more discouragement to the underprivileged, pulls jobs and wealth still further away, strikes another blow for the rich against the poorest. Another in an incessant rain of blows.
But it really doesn’t matter what the motivation of parents is. To use their children as an instrument against them speaks of a society that has divested itself of all values except the monetary. I realise Clare County Council are under a lot of pressure from our broken government, but they need to be deeply ashamed about this.
Oh, I have no dog in this fight by the way. The banking industry’s failure has already taken away all maintenance and fee support for postgraduates. I will have to borrow the money for my degree. And pay it back, with interest, to a bank.
Related articles
- Angry students slam grant blackmail threat’ – Press Release Free Education for Everyone (FEE) (cedarlounge.wordpress.com)
- Clare County Council & the Household Charge: What do you think? (newstalk.ie)
3 replies on “War On The Poor”
“This is just a clever ruse though. They believe people will be shamed into paying it.”
and
“To pay this tax is effectively to hand money over to a banker; not money that you ever owed to a banker, but money that a corrupt government promised to this banker. Why would you pay that?”
Not that I disagree with you on the sentiment against this (or in fact, nearly any tax), but under what statute doesn’t the Irish government have the right to levy taxes on anything they damn please? (Anything they damn please being the result of the process of duly elected officials, etc. etc.).
I dislike a lot of my taxes too, but not paying them would be illegal and eventually end with seizure of my assets and perhaps even jail time. It seems to me you’re arguing civil disobedience here. Or are you just thinking opportunistically: if enough people dodge this one, enforcement will become an impossibility (Cf. how the Dutch managed to duck the smoking ban to a degree).
In the end, I kinda worry about what you’re eventually arguing here. Because there’s one clear example of a European country that didn’t, doesn’t and doesn’t want to have its tax collection ducks in a row: Greece. Do you really want Ireland to be more like Greece? (and I don’t mean in regards to the weather).
I certainly respect their right to civil disobedience, and more and more I think it is becoming our only option.
And yes, I’d sooner we were more like Greece – sooner than continue to passively accept this level of exploitation.
I’d even sooner we were more like Iceland.
[…] think it’s bad here, where if you don’t pay a tax your children could be kept out of university. In Germany, they’ll refuse to bury […]